When you win playing online casino games, Canadian laws do not see these winnings as income to be taxed. This is because, in the eyes of the law, a player’s winning amount is due to luck, not an expectation. Canada does not tax gambling winnings because they are not considered a constant source of income, although “an individual may be subject to tax on income derived from gambling itself, if the.

1. Are Us Casino Winnings Taxable In Canada
2. Are Gambling Winnings Taxed In Canada
3. Are Casino Winnings Taxable In Canada
4. Are Online Gambling Winnings Taxable In Canada

Gambling, Casino Winnings and Taxes: The Canada-U.S. Tax Treaty

We charge a flat low rate, not a % of your refund, quoted upfront, which remains unchanged 95% of the time. Any changes to our fee as result of unexpected additional work will be discussed with you first.

Claiming Gaming & Casino Tax Refunds for Over 15 Years. We’ve been claiming gaming and casino tax refunds since 2003.
Gaming & Casino Tax Refund Eligibility:
– You are not a US citizen, Green card holder or resident
– Won taxable gaming, gambling income from specified gaming activity within the last three years.
– You have been issued an IRS Form 1042-S by the casino (the casino usually keeps up to 30% of your winnings as withholding tax and sends it to the IRS)
– You have either have an ITIN (US tax identification number) or we can apply for one on your behalf.
– You have qualified gaming losses (in accordance with the 1996 Canadian/US Tax Treaty).
The IRS rule allows you to go back three years to claim a refund. Taxes on wagering winnings prior to this period are statute-barred from any recovery

Canadian residents who go to Las Vegas and other USA venues for gambling may end up to be lucky and win a large amount of money. Is the gain taxable in the U.S.? Are gambling losses deductible against the winnings? Does IRS require the Casino to withheld taxes? The answer is yes to all three questions.

However, the good news is that under the Canada-U.S. Income tax treaty (Article XXII) Canadian residents are entitled to claim any U.S. wagering losses up to the amount of U.S. gambling gains for the year, using the same rule that would apply to U.S. citizens and residents. For U.S. citizens and resident aliens i.e. Green Card holders, gambling, betting, and lottery winnings or gains are usually taxable and must be declared when filing their 1040 income tax return, but gambling gains can be reduced by deducting gambling losses to the extent of their gambling gains. Generally for non-US gamblers, U.S. tax is withheld on any gains at source, but the winner cannot deduct any gambling losses to claim a refund of taxes withheld from gambling gains. But Article XXII has changed all of that for Canadian gamblers. In order to recover gambling taxes withheld, Canadian residents will have to file form 1040NR, U.S. Non-resident Alien Income Tax Return under provisions of the aforementioned United States-Canada income tax treaty.

Gambling winnings taxation laws are significantly different between Canada and the U.S. In Canada, all winnings arising from any kind gambling including casino plays, lottery, are generally exempt from taxable income provided it can be established that winnings are clearly not related to an office, employment, or property. With very few exceptions, Canadian income tax code does not treat betting and gambling as a dealing in any kind of trade or business activity. For now, Canadians winning gambling gains at home are entitled to get all they win, with no income tax consequences.

In the United States, taxation of gambling gains is treated totally different. Under U.S. law, gambling winnings of U.S. persons over $1200 excluding winnings on blackjack, baccarat, craps, roulette, and the big-6 wheel are considered taxable income. Whereas for Non-resident aliens including Canadians, their gambling winnings are subject to 30% withholding of the total win at source. For example if you win $1600, you’ll be walking out with only $1120. The more you win, the more you’ll lose as a result of gambling withholding taxes.

In 1996 Article XXII of the Canada-U.S. Tax Treaty was signed between the two countries. Under provisions of the Treaty, Canadians are eligible to file US income tax (1040NR) and claim their U.S.-source gambling losses from their U.S.-source gambling winnings, and recover casino taxes withheld at source and receive a refund. Total losses deducted cannot be more than total winnings.

In order to file 1040NR to recover casino tax refund, you need to obtain or already have a valid Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN). U.S.1040NR returns are filed annually and will cover your entire gambling wins and losses for that year. You are advised to seek professional gambling tax recovery advice, as this can be a tedious and complicated process.

To qualify for casino gambling tax recovery under Article XXII of the Canada-U.S. Tax Treaty, you must be able to prove all of your U.S.-related gambling losses. Good record keeping showing all wins and losses made in the U.S., including dates, times, locations, and amounts won and lost is very important. You should keep any statements issued by the casino, wager tickets, casino credit records, and bank withdrawal statements.

Gambling Winnings and US Taxes Refund for Canadians
Lost and Wone Money When Gambling in the United States? How Canadian Residents Can Get a Refund of 30% Withholding Tax?

We can help you get it back! Here it is how:

– File US tax return 1040NR

– Obtain U.S individual taxpayer identification number (“ITIN”) if you do not have one or the one you have has expired.

– File W7 and required documents with your 1040NR

– Make sure you keep record of your losses (bank withdraws, tickets, etc…)

According IRS Publication 515, no tax is imposed on nonbusiness gambling income a non-resident alien wins playing black-jack, baccarat, craps, roulette, or big-6 wheel in the United States. If you were issued form 1042-S and taxes were withheld you might be able to recover part or all of it . Contact Fairtax Business Services.

Tutorial for Canadian Gamblers:

Are Us Casino Winnings Taxable In Canada

Here is a short tutorial on how to Claim US Gambling Taxes Withheld at source from your winnings from the IRS.
Canadians who gamble and win at any United States casino may be subject to a 30% tax withheld off of their winnings.
According to Canada-US tax treaty it may be possible to ask the IRS (U.S. Internal Revenue Service) to send you some or all of that money back.

Introduction:
Suppose you won some money in a U.S.A Casino say in Vegas. The casino will keep 30% of your total jackpot amount, regardless of your losses (wagers) and will issue you a form called 1042-S, which will be sent by the casino to the IRS. But Canada-US tax treaty allows you to ask the IRS to consider the total amount you spent gambling during the whole year as deductable, resulting in reduced or zero amount of taxes you’d owe.

Example:

Are Gambling Winnings Taxed In Canada

You won $5,000 in 2018. You lost $4, 000 in 2018
your net win is $5,000-$4,000= 1,000.
Taxes withheld by the Casino at 30% of $5000: $15, 00.
Your actual winning was 5000-4000 = 1000, 30% of 1,000 = $300.
You can file a 2018 1040NR return in 2019 and ask the IRS to refund you the difference. $15, 00-$300= $1,200

NOTE: Make sure you can provide the IRS proof of any losses you claim. There is always a chance that IRS might select you for an audit at a later date and if you can’t prove the losses you initially claimed you will have to pay everything back plus possible penalty and interest. The only way to legally claim a full refund is if your losses were equal more money than your winnings for the year.

To request a recovery of taxes withheld and get a refund, you must file a US Non-Resident Tax Return (1040NR) with the IRS. And all of all of the following must apply to you:

– A Canadian resident
– Not a US citizen, Green card holder, nor eligible to obtain a US Social Security Number.
– Have both won and spent some money to win in Gambling activities in the US

Filling for Refund:
1- Complete a 1040NR Tax Return
2- W-7 and a certified copy of your Canadian passport if you do not have a valid ITIN number
3- 1402-S issued by the Casino
Mail the package to:

Internal Revenue Service
ITIN Operation
P.O. Box 149342
Austin, TX, USA
78714-9342

Are Casino Winnings Taxable In Canada

Introduction – Taxation of Gambling and Sources of Income

In the Canadian income tax system, only income which can be traced from a 'source' is considered taxable. The accepted sources of income under the Income Tax Act are:

1. Office
2. Employment
3. Business
4. Property
5. Other sources

While 'other sources' is rather vague, it is commonly accepted that windfalls, gifts, inheritances, strike pay, and lottery winnings, just to mention a few, are not considered sources of income for income tax purposes. Winnings from gambling on the other hand are slightly different in that they are also generally non-taxable, but, if considered to be part of a business, become taxable.

Hobby vs Business

To determine whether gambling is undertaken as a hobby or as a business, the Supreme Court of Canada has laid out a test in Stewart v. Canada. The Stewart test is a two part test: 1) is the taxpayer's activity undertaken in pursuit of profit, or is it a personal endeavour; 2) if it is not a personal endeavour, is the source of the income business or property. Where a taxpayer's venture has elements that suggest it could be considered a hobby or other personal pursuit, then the venture will only be considered a source of income if it is undertaken in a sufficiently commercial manner. For gambling, only the first part of the test is relevant – if part 1 is satisfied, then for part 2 of the test, gambling winnings default to business income as they are almost in all circumstances not going to be income from property.

In terms of whether the subjective intent in undertaking the activity is for the pursuit of profit, for gambling, this subjective intent is essentially always exists to some extent just by the nature of gambling. Since that is the case, a determination needs to be made as to whether the predominant intention is to profit. Finally, the gambling activity needs to be carried out in accordance with objective standards of businesslike behaviour. If those elements are met, then the gambling activity will be considered a business activity and any wins or losses will be taxed accordingly. Call our top Toronto tax firm and learn more about how to differentiate between a hobby and a business.

Standards of Businesslike Behaviour

It is important not to equate a successful venture with businesslike behaviour. While running a venture is likely to increase the chance of success, mere evidence of profit doesn't make a venture a business. It is inappropriate to simply look backwards and conclude a profitable venture must be a business and an unprofitable venture must not have been run with sufficiently businesslike behaviour. This was made clear in Leblanc v. The Queen where two brothers purchased sports lottery tickets on a massive scale. They made approximately $50 million in bets and earned a profit of approximately $5 million. Additionally, they would try to make deals with ticket vendors to get discounts on bulk purchases and hired helpers to visit different vendor locations and purchase tickets. However, the Court in analysing their conduct determined that the objective standards of businesslike behaviour were not met. Amongst other things, the judge found that the Leblanc brothers had no system involved in their gambling that would mitigate risk and or increase their chances of winning. The judge found that they bet massively and recklessly and were successful simply due to good luck.

On the other hand, a key case where gambling winnings were found to be business income was in the case of Luprypa v. The Queen. Luprypa involved a skilled pool player who made approximately $1,000 a week playing staked pool games against bar patrons. However, what differentiates Luprypa is that he carefully managed the risks, focused on an area where he was particularly skilled, and involved a system to maximize his chances of winning. Specifically, he would only play staked games after 11pm and would target inebriated bar patrons while remaining entirely sober. Furthermore, in the afternoons, he would consistently practice playing pool to perfect his skills.

Taxability of Poker Winnings

Poker differs from many other gambling activities in that is considered that skilled players can significantly increase their chances of winning and can make a consistent profit playing. Cohen v. The Queen is a key case specifically addressing poker where a lawyer quit his job and became a professional poker player. He initially read books and articles on poker strategy and how to use math to increase his chances of winning and testified that he had a strategy where he would focus on playing against inexperienced players and win a high volume of small stakes games. The judge in Cohen listed out 5 factors that he considered in making a determination of whether there was evidence of a poker business:

1. Profit and loss experience in past years;
2. Taxpayer's training;
3. Taxpayer's intended course of action;
4. The capability of the venture to show a profit;
5. Other factors from Luprypa

In this case, the taxpayer just started his professional poker career and had no past history so factor 1 was inapplicable. On factor 2, the judge found that, while the taxpayer did have some evidence of researching poker strategy and that he attended a poker seminar, he did not have any special training nor was his knowledge or skill in poker unusual or beyond that of a normal poker player. The judge also noted that as an example of his point, many hobby chess players own enough game strategy books to fill a small library, but that in itself does not make one a professional chess player and similarly, possessing that type of material does not make one a professional poker player. Factor 3 was an analysis of the taxpayer's business plan and overall strategy and the judge found that there was no overall business plan and that his strategy of minimizing risk by playing low stakes games was quickly abandoned by the taxpayer as he began to play high stake games with more experienced players. On factor 4, the judge similarly found that there was no evidence that substantiated the taxpayer had a business plan, with no budget, proper records of the number of games he played or how much he won in any particular game, and was inconsistent with a venture that had the capacity for profit. Finally, factor 5 considered the factors in Luprypa, many of which overlap with the first 4 factors, but essentially the judge was not convinced that the taxpayer showed any particular skill, did not see any evidence of a system which would increase his chances of winning and minimize risk. As such, the judge concluded in Cohen that the poker activities were not conducted in a sufficiently businesslike manner and thus denied the losses that the taxpayer claimed.

Are Online Gambling Winnings Taxable In Canada

Tax Tip – Take Care When Claiming Gambling Losses

The take home on this subject is that gambling is rarely considered a business venture unless a coherent 'system' is being used to minimize risk and maximize the chance of winning. Furthermore, this 'system' needs to be more than what a reasonably enthusiastic hobbyist would do. What this means is that Cana dians who are casually gambling should not be particularly worried that their gambling winnings will be taxed. The flip side of this is that losses from gambling are also difficult to claim as the standard for businesslike behaviour in a gambling context is extremely high. If you think you have significant profits or losses from gambling and think you might meet the requirements for businesslike behaviour, speak to one of our experienced Toronto tax lawyers and make sure you won't be surprised by a big tax bill or miss out on claiming a valid business loss.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

Alter Ego Trusts And Joint Spousal Trusts: Beware Of The TrapsThe Tax Benefits Of A Personal Real Estate Corporation Tax Guidance To Canada Revenue Agency's Extended Work-from-home Reimbursement To Home Office Equipment – A Canadian Tax Lawyer's AnalysisTaxation Of Shareholders: The Basic Deemed-Dividend Tax Rules—A Canadian Tax Lawyer's AnalysisCanada's Fall Economic Statement: Tax HighlightsWhen Your Employees Work In Canada: Income Tax Help For Non-Canadian EmployersRELATED CONTENT